Powergaming: On

← Back

← Previous Post (Age of Worms Part 6)

The Spire of Long Shadows

This is the seventh installment in The Age of Worms, meant for characters of 13th-15th level.

Here Be Dragons!

Five red dragons seen from different angles, undulating gently.

This article contains substantial information about the Age of Worms adventure path. Players beware!

Adventure Summary

Seeking the researcher Balakarde and information about the looming Overgod Kyuss, the PCs head to the long-lost city of Kuluth-Mar. There, they'll find the remnants of the city that Kyuss sacrificed in his ascent to godhood and fight against the ancient sage who set him on his path to power.

Initial Impressions

Ooh, this is a fun one.

Ok, as a dungeon the Spire of Long Shadows isn't spectacular. The layout is extremely simple. Unless your players choose to delve into the mid-level tunnels, and you oblige by fleshing out and improvising that section, there's not much in the way of rewarding exploration. But the combats? Now those are good!

This is one of the only times I've run a prewritten, high level adventure that really felt like the writers actually understood high level play. The inhabitants of this dungeon range from dangerous to deadly. The various encounters on the ground floor are the first time that I've ever run a prewritten combat above EL 10 without changing a single thing. It wasn't just challenging for my players, it was almost deadly. Before a few tactically good turns managed to turn the tide in their favor they were considering whether it was time to retreat.

(Caveat: this is true in part because I was generous about the sounds of combat alerting the various enemies and drawing them out of their default rooms. Obviously this is a realistic way to run intelligent cohabitating creatures, but if you want to keep things less deadly you could simply keep the doors shut.)

The problem is the structure. Ooh, I hate this adventure structure. Why do so many adventure modules do this?

The narrative justification for this adventure is that the players are exploring the city Kyuss ruled when he was human. They're learning about who he was and what happened to bring him to power.

Instead of using literally any other method of conveying this information, various places and actions trigger Magical Visions which show the players what happened in the past.

I hate this! I hate it so bad! I've seen this in multiple adventure paths. Why have multiple writers decided that the best way to do exposition is to randomly drop the PCs into spooky cutscenes?

It's the randomness that really gets me. It's not like the PCs are getting visions from artifacts or sites of power. They're just wandering through the dungeon, and occasionally if they happen to trigger a vision they get a little movie-quality snippet of Kyuss' life. I find this boring, unmotivating, and overall a terrible way to provide exposition.

Sorcery in Combat

The standout for this adventure is the fight against Mak'ar, Harbinger of Worms. The true architect behind the Age of Worms, he put Kyuss on the path to godhood, setting in motion a prophecy that would take thousands of years to fulfill.

Mak'ar is a creature called a Spell Weaver, which first appeared in the Monster Manual II. These monsters are able to use each of their 6 arms to independently work magic, allowing them to cast as many as 6 spells simultaneously. This is a fantastic way to address the main problem that spellcasters face when trying to perform as lone enemies: with, normally, only one spell per round, the action economy is simply not in their favor. Generally I would advise equipping him with arcane spellsurge to make his turns even more devastating, but I actually find it better to allow him to reserve his swift actions, because they draw from the same pool as immediate actions. More on this below.

Mak'ar's fight is not at all bad as written, but the possibilities of magic use are endless, so let's talk about ways to make a spellcaster fight the best it can be. Here I'll focus on defense. Compared to other opponents, magic-users have tiny hp pools and often very little armor to hide behind. If you don't use their powerful magic for defense as much as for offense, they'll quickly get KO'ed.

(We will not be talking about polymorph and its cousins; those are very powerful and lend themselves to a completely different playstyle.)

There's little point in attempting to shore up Mak'ar's meager hp pool, though you could do so by giving him the Unholy Toughness extraordinary ability that some of the later undead in the path have; this allows Mak'ar's hp bonus be calculated with his charisma instead of his constitution, more than tripling his hp. But a spellcaster who's taken damage is a spellcaster who's already dead. The question for a Mak'ar isn't so much how many hits he can take: it's what it takes to even hit him in the first place.

To some extent, your players shouldn't feel like they're fighting the sorcerer; the sorcerer will lose. They should feel as though they're fighting through the environment just to get a chance to be able to strike at the sorcerer. And then the sorcerer should pull some bullshit that causes them to automatically miss and puts them right back at square one. A lot of the fun in such fights should lie in forcing your players to abandon their usual tools and get creative!

Accordingly, I first looked for spells that Mak'ar can use to shape the battlefield in his favor. The many fog-creating spells like cloudkill and solid fog are excellent choices because they block sight and movement. Wall spells can be interesting but tricky to deploy effectively at high levels; still, starting the fight by putting up a prismatic wall would make for a flavorful encounter! Teleporting PCs can be prevented from circumventing these movement blocks by dimensional anchor. You can also play with sight; Mak'ar can easily use greater invisibility, and blacklight denies vision to the PCs but not to him.

Once they've managed to get line of sight on their opponent, the PCs will need to contend with his personal defenses. Sometimmes you can almost make this into a puzzle of figuring which damage types your enemy is or is not immune to. Ironguard and the various heart of spells are excellent choices; you should also assume that, unless the PCs have specifically defended themselves from scrying, Mak'ar has watched their battles and cast energy immunity or at least protection from energy or resist energy against their favorite damage sources. He can also use Otiluke's supressing field to deny the PCs their favorite school of magic, so long as it doesn't overlap with his own. Again, it will only take one or two hits to destroy him, so the goal is to make actually hitting as difficult as possible.

Once your players have got eyes on Mak'ar, should he counterspell them? Countering spells can be tricky; its efficacy depends largely on whether Mak'ar is a higher caster level than your party. If he is, then pulling out a greater dispel magic can be a great way to force your players to improvise. Twists on this include dispelling screen, reciprocal gyre, and reaving dispel. But if your players have been boosting their caster level, then it's an exercise in futility and only reciprocal gyre remains worthwhile.

(As a side note, actually using dispel magic in play is a bit terrible; as written, when you use it on a character you must individually roll for each spell currently affecting them - including effects from magic items, almost certainly necessitating that you look up the caster level of every individual item they carry. I suggest establishing with your players beforehand how you're going to speed this up, because it sucks in play. We use the high-risk, high-reward option that you make a single roll against the highest-caster-level spell in order to dispel all of them.)

Instead of counterspelling, I focus on other uses of immediate actions. The simple choices are greater mirror image and wings of cover. I equip nearly every spellcaster with them, and your players are probably using them too. Get greater mirror image up as quickly as possible to turn sure hits into a 1-in-7, then use wings of cover against the most dangerous-seeming attack your players deploy. Use Mak'ar's intelligence here once more; he'll accept low-risk whacks if he knows that he'll be better served saving his immediate action to use against a dispelling ray or other major attack, and again unless the PCs have been defending against scrying he should know their favored tactics. In turn your players should get to notice this tactic and have fun by finding ways to bait out his immediate action before deploying their most powerful attacks.

When Mak'ar is finally hit, well, he's had plenty of time in his years under the spire to set up a contingency. I would use this to teleport him away to interrupt the battle and give him a chance to heal and recover, but you can certainly get more creative. Let phase two begin!

That's enough on spellcasting for now; in a future installment I'll talk more about offensive spells and about polymorphing enemies.

Exposition

I've indicated that I'm not a fan of this adventure's exposition structure. It's a ton of lore-dumping that will likely go in one ear and out the other, and metaphysically the "visions" are very poorly motivated. How can we make this type of exposition more relevant and interesting to our players?

One major problem: the stuff the players learn about Kyuss here doesn't actually matter very much. The person they're following is Balakarde, but they'll find no trace of him in the Spire. Instead, they'll learn a ton about the vague history of Kyuss, which is satisfying to know but offers them no information on how to stop him.

For Balakarde, I decided that he had met and bargained with the worm naga sorcerer Sruggat. He was able to escape the bored worm naga by turning over his journal - Sruggat's first new book to read in a millenium. Sruggat will eagerly discuss the only interesting thing that's happened to him since getting trapped, and told Balakarde, as he will tell the PCs, various rambling stories about Kyuss's ascension ritual and the fall of Kuluth-Mar. Balakarde's journal fragment, which Lashonna gives in the PCs in The Library of Last Resort, is instead located here. It can be found in Sruggat's library, or the worm naga might be reluctantly persuaded to hand it over in exchange for his freedom or for a pile of newer and more interesting books. This way, your players can actually get their question answered and feel they've accomplished something by coming here.

Mak'ar, who's personally invested in the coming of the Age of Worms, will also happily talk to the PCs about his teaching of Kyuss and the coming apocalypse, relating much of the information encountered in the visions. He should also repeatedly mention that Kyuss has escaped Kuluth-Mar, taunting the PCs about their inevitable failure. Tales of the day and histories recounting the arrival of Mak'ar can also be found in the spire's library's, pieced together from the fallen architecture, or seen depicted in fragments in ancient wall paintings. The only visions I kept were those triggered by touching the worm pools - these clearly powerful magical resevoirs provide a reason for the event to occur. This should be sufficient to satisfy your players' curiosity about who Kyuss is and what happened here.

The final remaining point is the stolen spire. Emphasize the broken top of the spire from your first description of it, and make sure that through either the wall paintings or conversation it's clear to the players that Kyuss was trapped inside it. The missing spire drives the tension of the final part of the adventure; finding it is the only way to prevent Kyuss' return, and in order to lead into the next adventure we need to establish that the dracolich Dragotha was the one who stole the spire.

If you're willing to put in the work, by far the best way to include this would be to leverage the brief comments about the factions surrounding the spire. Once it's made clear to the players that they need to find the spire, they might try to find a witness to its theft. None of the Kyussspawn will speak unless the PCs manage to find a way to force them, but Ballaxus the beholder might have witnessed the event and be willing to exchange the information for the murder of his new rival Boshliwur, or the yuan-ti in the eastern quarter may remember the event if the PCs can manage to approach them peacefully.

If that sounds like too much work, the lazy version is that Mak'ar knows it was Dragotha who stole the spire, and he taunts the PCs with the knowledge that they have no chance against the world's mightiest dracolich.

In my own campaign, one of my players wanted to play a diviner, so I actually seeded Dragotha's presence from the beginning. The movements of such a powerful creature are reflected in the stars. Occasionally, in their dreams or when they attempted divinations, I would give them hints of information recieved from this adventure's visions. I particularly focused on the notion of a dragon carrying a heavy object across the ocean and away to the north. Confronted with the missing spire, my players quickly made the connection.

The above is partially dependent on a change I made to the timeline. As written, Dragotha stole the spire some unknown amount of time in the past. Instead, I moved this timeline up so that Dragotha is right now working on implementing his plan. He flew across the ocean with the broken spire on the same day my PCs arrived in The Free City; eventually, rumors from sailors could indicate sightings of an enormous dragon. This does two things for me. First, it lets me use current rumors and sightings to indicate Dragotha's movements and foreshadow his involvement. Second, it makes the Age of Worms into an actual race against time, helping avoid the appearance that this apocalypse could have happened basically whenever but waited for the PCs to arrive.

Final Thoughts

One of the best adventures in Age of Worms combat-wise, if weak structurally.

Spellcaster fights are fun! They're difficult to run, but they provide an opportunity to shake things up. That's always my goal with these fights: how do I take away my player's comfortable default options and force them to use a different tool? Making them improvise will ensure a fight is harrowing and memorable regardless of how much damage gets slung around.

Five green dragons seen from different angles, undulating gently.