Here Be Dragons!
This article contains substantial information about Rappan Athuk: The Dungeon of Graves. Players beware!
← Back
← Previous Post (Rappan Athuk Level 4A)
Here Be Dragons!
This article contains substantial information about Rappan Athuk: The Dungeon of Graves. Players beware!
I don't have a ton to say here; the 5th level is mostly a passingthrough that provides routes to other parts of the dungeons, and there's little about the encounters on offer that we haven't already seen.
Even Banth's tactics are unusually good for a wizard! He has tanky friends in front of him, and while you should probably assume he has at least some of his buffs cast in advance the notion that he starts out with wall of force to give himself time is a good one. Just be careful of what spells can and can't be cast through it.
Except, unfortunately, that Tenser's transformation is an awful spell, even as a last resort. The benefits it gives you simply don't stack up against the loss of your spells. As an 11th-level transmuter, Banth has access to much more powerful ways to enter melee. He should instead use polymorph (or, even better, draconic polymorph) to transform into a bruiser like a chuul or a hydra. If you want to maintain the feel of him going from Jekyll to Hyde, the bloodrager troll and grey render are also good choices.
Ah, the maze. What do we do with the maze?
For parties who make it past the first few death traps, this is certainly the most infamous aspect of the dungeon. "Mazes" are essentially areas where you are supposed to waste the party's time out of game as much as in. Explicit instructions are given to the DM to give random incorrect directions unless the party makes a DC 30 Intuit Direction (Survival in 3.5) check, as the maze makes it difficult even to determine left from right. Walls undetectably slide back and forth whenever the players turn their backs, and undetectable teleportals fling them randomly about the area.
So, like, what's the point? I can see the faint remnants of some old-school dungeon crawling here, but it doesn't seem fun. For me, a lot of these games is about getting to express system mastery; that is, getting to work at a skill and become good at it. In combats, we express both our ability to build an effective character and our ability to make tactical decisions about a particular situation. In a confusing maze like this, we could express our ability to keep track of a space and find a path through it. But if the DM is lying to you, you have no opportunity to express any mastery at all. It's just an exercise in frustration!
This is compounded by the module offering only one maze section and instructing the DM to make up the others; improvising this type of complex puzzle space is unlikely to go well.
So what can we do instead?
Option 1: ignore them. The mazes should theoretically provide a physical barrier that makes it difficult to leave the dungeon, but your party will soon have access to teleport which will entirely obviate this challenge. Replace them with descriptions of long winding tunnels and a wondering monster check.
Option 2: replace them with a simple navigation check. The party enters a clearly magically-warped area filled with crisscrossing tunnels. A succesful navigation check gets them through in an hour, a failed check gets them, say, 4 wasted hours and a wandering monster encounter. These will be less engaging as physical puzzles, but they'll be simple to run and allow you to put time pressure on your players. If they overnight in a maze they might risk waking up in a different maze altogther.
Option 3: put in the work to make it an actual navigation puzzle for your players. Stealing basic map patterns from Zelda dungeons is not a bad way to start here, especially A Link to the Past's Skull Woods and Ice Palace. Using mechanics like the sliding doors or teleportals the module discusses, your players can attempt to navigate this magically-warped area and figure out which rooms to go through in which order to escape the maze. Roll wandering monster chances at a set frequency to keep up the time pressure, but consider also rolling encounter distance - the players might peek through a door to see an inattentive chimera and choose to go a different way. Intuit Direction checks can get them some notion of whether the map they've drawn is accurate, and spells like knock and passwall can blast through a problem but are in limited supply. This will be a lot of work for you, but if you and your players are all having fun with it it will genuinely reward your players' skills in a satisfying way.
Option 4: play Shadowdark instead.
Some decent encounters here, but the mazes are the epitome of Rappan Athuk's confused approach to its "First Edition Feel." The writers seem unclear on what is challenging or fun about the material they're writing, they can't implement their ideas without arbitrarily declaring that certain spells just don't work here, and they foist extra work onto the DM to fill in the gaps.
But there is much to enjoy here! The spooky poisoned tunnels are a good challenge at this level; they're obviously wierd, cueing PCs to investigate before stepping in. The tomb of Ereg Tal is a fun little sidequest, the will-o'-wisp caverns are thematically in character with being lost in winding tunnels deep underground, and the magical mushrooms are an actually fun bit of old-school "what's this wierd thing I found" gameplay. Goblins trapped here can provide more clues about the mines and Grezneck. Lean into those, decide in advance how to deal with the maze sections, and have a good time.